View single post by srossi
 Posted: Mon Jan 12th, 2009 10:29 pm
PM Quote Reply Full Topic


Joined: Sun Oct 14th, 2007
Location: New York USA
Posts: 52481
Sometimes you just have to go with your gut and you know who's a HOFer and who isn't.  Rice stood out as a HOFer, McGriff was merely a very good player.  I'd say Dawson was a HOFer well above McGriff too.  Same thing with Mattingly vs. Grace.  The toughest call for me is Edgar Martinez.  As a Yankee fan, I can tell you that he was the one guy in the league who I lease wanted to see at the plate.  And his overall numbers are amazing too.  For some reason I never thought of him as a HOFer though, but I wouldn't complain if he got in.   

This thread was great before AA ruined it.