View single post by stingmark
 Posted: Thu Oct 4th, 2012 04:22 am
PM Quote Reply Full Topic


Joined: Mon Oct 15th, 2007
Location: Cop City, California USA
Posts: 9397
Principal_Raditch wrote:
stingmark wrote: Principal_Raditch wrote: You're only look at Offence though. Trout's a gold glover, Cabrera might be the worst 3b in MLB. So Offensively Cabrera has a slight advantage. On the basepaths, Trout has a massive advantage. Defensively Trout has a massive advantage. It's a close call.

They dont give a player the TC because of defense, as it's an offensive based award, so your argument about his defense, is moot as it pertains to the TC. I believe Cabrera isĀ  a gold glover in the past. He switched positions so that Fielder could play first base, I would guess that if you were the manager, you'd probably do something similar.

Then how did Jimmy Rollins win the MVP with shittier offensive numbers than at least 4 other players in 2007? I was talking about winning an MVP based on overall ability, not TC.

Not sure, mvp is not the tc, why are you asking me about something that happened 5 yrs ago, that neither of us had control over or say so on. I didnt vote for him, ask the voters. They make boo boos all the time, If Cabrera wins mvp, will you have the same issues with it as well?

Last edited on Thu Oct 4th, 2012 04:24 am by stingmark

"I went to the #6th ranked liberal Arts College in California, I'm smarter than anyone else"(Also found out to be a formerly racist institution-Jeff Forsyth)